20% Endowment Growth: Strategic Management Approach

20% Endowment Growth: Strategic Management Approach

Executive Summary

The Harrington Community Foundation, a vital local philanthropic organization, faced stagnant endowment growth, limiting its capacity to fund crucial community initiatives. Golden Door Asset, through its affiliated advisory firm Harrington Legacy Advisors, implemented a strategic investment management approach focusing on diversified asset allocation and long-term, sustainable returns. This tailored strategy, aligned with the foundation’s risk tolerance and philanthropic goals, resulted in a significant 20% increase in the endowment's value over three years, enabling the foundation to substantially expand its charitable giving and community impact.

The Challenge

The Harrington Community Foundation, dedicated to supporting local arts, education, and social services, held an endowment of $5 million. For the five years prior to engaging Harrington Legacy Advisors, the endowment had experienced minimal growth, averaging a meager 1.5% annual return. This performance barely kept pace with inflation, effectively diminishing the endowment's real value and hindering its ability to significantly impact the community.

The foundation's investment committee, comprised of well-intentioned but non-expert volunteers, primarily allocated the endowment to a mix of large-cap equity index funds and fixed-income securities, a relatively conservative but ultimately underperforming strategy. Their investment policy statement (IPS), while outlining a preference for socially responsible investing (SRI), lacked specific guidelines and clear benchmarks for measuring performance beyond simple returns. This lack of clarity led to inconsistent investment decisions and limited opportunities for generating the necessary growth to meet the foundation’s expanding grant-making objectives.

Specifically, the foundation aimed to increase its annual grant distributions from $200,000 to $300,000 within five years to address growing needs in local youth programs. However, at the previous growth rate, the endowment was projected to fall short of this goal by an estimated $750,000 by the end of that period, significantly impacting the foundation's ability to fulfill its mission. Furthermore, the foundation worried that future market downturns could further erode the endowment, making it even more difficult to achieve its objectives. The existing investment strategy simply wasn't sufficient to support their ambitious philanthropic goals.

The Approach

Harrington Legacy Advisors began by conducting a thorough review of the Harrington Community Foundation's existing investment portfolio, IPS, and grant-making goals. This involved in-depth conversations with the investment committee and key stakeholders to fully understand their risk tolerance, time horizon, and philanthropic priorities.

Based on this comprehensive assessment, Harrington Legacy Advisors developed a customized investment strategy designed to maximize long-term growth while aligning with the foundation's SRI principles and maintaining a prudent level of risk. The core of this strategy involved implementing Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT) to construct a diversified portfolio across a wider range of asset classes, including:

• Domestic Equities (35%): A blend of large-cap, mid-cap, and small-cap stocks, with a tilt towards value and dividend-paying companies. A portion was allocated to an ESG-focused exchange-traded fund (ETF) to reflect the foundation's SRI values.
• International Equities (20%): Exposure to developed and emerging market equities, providing diversification and access to potentially higher growth opportunities.
• Fixed Income (30%): A mix of U.S. Treasury bonds, corporate bonds, and municipal bonds, with a focus on investment-grade securities to provide stability and income.
• Alternative Investments (15%): A small allocation to private equity and real estate, offering the potential for higher returns and diversification benefits. These investments were carefully vetted to ensure alignment with the foundation's values and risk tolerance.

Furthermore, Harrington Legacy Advisors implemented a disciplined rebalancing strategy, designed to maintain the target asset allocation and take advantage of market fluctuations. The portfolio was reviewed quarterly and rebalanced annually, or more frequently if necessary, to ensure that it remained aligned with the foundation's investment objectives. Finally, a transparent and comprehensive reporting system was established to provide the investment committee with regular updates on portfolio performance, asset allocation, and investment strategy.

The strategic investment management also involved:

• Refinement of the IPS: Harrington Legacy Advisors worked with the investment committee to update the IPS, incorporating specific SRI guidelines, clear performance benchmarks, and a defined process for monitoring and evaluating investment performance.
• Educational Workshops: Providing ongoing educational workshops for the investment committee to enhance their understanding of investment concepts, portfolio management, and SRI principles.
• Regular Communication: Maintaining open and frequent communication with the investment committee to address their questions and concerns and ensure that they were fully informed about the investment strategy.

Technical Implementation

The construction of the diversified investment portfolio relied heavily on the principles of Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT). Utilizing Golden Door Asset’s proprietary asset allocation models, powered by AI and historical data analysis, Harrington Legacy Advisors optimized the portfolio to achieve the highest expected return for a given level of risk, based on the foundation's risk tolerance.

Specific tools and techniques employed included:

• Riskalyze: To accurately assess the foundation's risk tolerance and align the investment strategy accordingly. The risk score was determined to be a "55," indicating a moderate risk tolerance suitable for a balanced portfolio.
• Monte Carlo Simulations: To project the likelihood of achieving the foundation's grant-making goals under various market scenarios. These simulations helped to quantify the potential risks and rewards of the investment strategy.
• Black-Litterman Model: For incorporating the investment team's views on specific asset classes and market trends into the asset allocation process.
• FactSet and Bloomberg Terminal: Used for real-time market data, portfolio analysis, and performance reporting.
• Sharpe Ratio Analysis: To evaluate the risk-adjusted performance of the portfolio and compare it to relevant benchmarks. The target Sharpe Ratio was set at 0.75.
• Tax-Loss Harvesting: To minimize the tax impact of investment gains and losses.
• Rebalancing Algorithm: A rules-based rebalancing algorithm was implemented to automatically rebalance the portfolio whenever asset allocation deviates by more than 5% from the target allocation.
• ESG Screening: Utilized MSCI KLD Stats to ensure that all investments met the foundation's ethical and social responsibility criteria. This involved excluding companies involved in controversial industries such as tobacco, firearms, and fossil fuels.

Furthermore, Harrington Legacy Advisors leveraged Golden Door Asset's platform to automate portfolio monitoring and reporting. The platform's AI-powered analytics provided real-time insights into portfolio performance, risk exposures, and potential investment opportunities.

Results & ROI

The strategic investment management approach implemented by Harrington Legacy Advisors yielded significant results for the Harrington Community Foundation's endowment:

• Endowment Growth: The endowment's value increased from $5 million to $6 million over three years, representing a 20% overall growth.
• Annualized Return: The portfolio achieved an annualized return of 6.3%, significantly exceeding the previous five-year average of 1.5%.
• Grant Distributions: The foundation was able to increase its annual grant distributions from $200,000 to $250,000 within the first two years, and is on track to reach its goal of $300,000 by the end of the fifth year.
• Sharpe Ratio: The portfolio's Sharpe Ratio improved from 0.3 to 0.8, indicating a better risk-adjusted return.
• Benchmark Performance: The portfolio outperformed its benchmark, a blended index of 60% equities and 40% fixed income, by 1.2% per year.
• Impact on Community: The increased grant distributions enabled the foundation to support a greater number of local organizations and initiatives, significantly enhancing its impact on the community. For example, funding for a local after-school program increased by 30%, allowing them to serve an additional 50 children.
• Donor Confidence: The improved performance and transparent reporting boosted donor confidence, leading to increased donations and planned giving commitments.

Key Takeaways

1. Diversification is Key: A well-diversified portfolio across multiple asset classes can significantly enhance long-term returns and reduce risk. Don't rely solely on traditional asset classes like stocks and bonds.
2. Align Investments with Values: Integrating socially responsible investing (SRI) principles into the investment strategy can align the endowment with the foundation's mission and values, attracting donors and enhancing its reputation.
3. Regular Monitoring and Rebalancing: Consistent monitoring of portfolio performance and periodic rebalancing are essential for maintaining the target asset allocation and capturing potential investment opportunities.
4. Transparency and Communication: Open and transparent communication with the investment committee and other stakeholders is crucial for building trust and ensuring that everyone is aligned with the investment strategy.
5. Expert Guidance is Invaluable: Engaging a qualified financial advisor with expertise in endowment management can provide valuable insights, develop a customized investment strategy, and help the foundation achieve its philanthropic goals.

About Golden Door Asset

Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors build hyper-personalized investment strategies for their clients, optimizing for both returns and social impact preferences. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.