$50,000 Tax Savings Secured Through Proactive Planning for Client

$50,000 Tax Savings Secured Through Proactive Planning for Client

Executive Summary

A long-term client of New Horizons Wealth Management was facing a significant capital gains tax liability of approximately $85,000 following the sale of a highly appreciated technology stock. Realizing the potential impact on the client's net worth, Financial Advisor Rebecca Hayes proactively conducted a comprehensive tax analysis and implemented a strategic combination of tax-loss harvesting and charitable gifting. This forward-thinking approach resulted in a $50,000 reduction in the client's tax burden, significantly enhancing their financial well-being and solidifying their relationship with New Horizons.

The Challenge

John and Mary Smith had been loyal clients of New Horizons Wealth Management for over 15 years. Their portfolio, built carefully over time, included a significant position in a publicly traded technology company, acquired early in its growth phase. Over the years, this stock had appreciated considerably, representing a substantial portion of their overall net worth.

In early 2023, the Smiths decided to diversify their holdings and realized gains of $340,000 from the sale of this technology stock. While thrilled with the investment's performance, they were understandably concerned about the potential capital gains tax implications. Based on their income bracket and the long-term capital gains tax rate (assuming a combined federal and state rate of approximately 25%), their initial estimated tax liability was a daunting $85,000. This substantial tax bill would significantly impact their retirement savings and ability to pursue other financial goals, such as funding their grandchildren's education and making planned charitable donations.

Furthermore, the Smiths were also grappling with the underperformance of certain fixed income investments within their portfolio. While these investments were chosen for diversification and risk management, they had experienced losses totaling approximately $60,000 in the volatile market conditions of the previous year. This presented both a challenge and an opportunity: how could New Horizons mitigate the Smiths' tax burden from the realized capital gains while strategically repositioning their portfolio for future growth and stability?

The pressure was on for Rebecca Hayes, their dedicated financial advisor at New Horizons, to develop a plan that would minimize the Smiths' tax liability and ensure their long-term financial security. Failure to address this issue proactively could not only negatively impact the Smiths' financial well-being but also potentially damage their trust in New Horizons' ability to effectively manage their wealth.

The Approach

Rebecca Hayes recognized that a reactive, "wait-and-see" approach would be detrimental to the Smiths' financial situation. Instead, she adopted a proactive and multi-faceted strategy focused on maximizing tax efficiency and optimizing their portfolio for long-term growth.

Her first step was to conduct a thorough tax analysis using specialized tax planning software, CCH ProSystem fx Tax. This software allowed her to model various scenarios and identify potential tax-saving opportunities based on the Smiths' income, deductions, and investment holdings.

Knowing the Smiths' philanthropic inclinations, Rebecca explored the potential benefits of charitable gifting. She discussed the option of donating appreciated securities directly to a qualified charity, allowing the Smiths to deduct the fair market value of the donated securities while avoiding capital gains taxes on the appreciation. This option aligned perfectly with their values and offered a significant tax advantage.

Simultaneously, Rebecca evaluated the Smiths' underperforming fixed income investments for tax-loss harvesting opportunities. Tax-loss harvesting involves selling assets that have declined in value to offset capital gains. She identified $50,000 in losses that could be realized without significantly altering the overall risk profile of the portfolio.

Rebecca then engaged in a collaborative conversation with the Smiths' CPA to ensure all strategies were aligned with their overall tax plan and to navigate any potential complexities related to state and local tax regulations. This collaboration was crucial to ensuring the plan's feasibility and maximizing its effectiveness.

Finally, Rebecca presented the Smiths with a comprehensive plan outlining the proposed tax-loss harvesting and charitable gifting strategies, along with a clear explanation of the potential tax savings and the implications for their portfolio allocation. She emphasized the importance of understanding the risks and benefits of each strategy and encouraged them to ask questions and express any concerns.

Technical Implementation

The tax planning process relied heavily on CCH ProSystem fx Tax, a professional-grade tax software that allowed for detailed simulations and calculations. Specifically, Rebecca used the software to:

1. Project Capital Gains Tax Liability: The software accurately calculated the capital gains tax liability based on the $340,000 realized gain, factoring in the applicable federal and state tax rates. This provided a baseline against which to measure the effectiveness of the proposed tax-saving strategies.

2. Model Tax-Loss Harvesting Scenarios: Rebecca used the software to simulate the impact of selling the underperforming fixed income investments, realizing $50,000 in losses. The software automatically calculated the amount of capital gains that could be offset by these losses, as well as any potential carryover losses that could be used in future years.

3. Analyze Charitable Gifting Options: The software allowed Rebecca to model the tax benefits of donating appreciated securities to a qualified charity. She considered various scenarios, including different amounts and types of securities, to determine the optimal donation strategy. She ensured the qualified charity was a 501(c)(3) organization and that all necessary documentation was in place for claiming the deduction.

4. Coordinate with the CPA: Communication with the Smiths’ CPA was crucial. Rebecca provided the CPA with detailed reports generated by CCH ProSystem fx Tax, outlining the proposed tax-saving strategies and their potential impact on the Smiths' overall tax situation. They discussed the plan's feasibility, identified any potential challenges, and ensured compliance with all applicable tax laws and regulations. The CPA confirmed that the Smiths' adjusted gross income (AGI) allowed for the full deduction of the charitable donation and that the tax-loss harvesting strategy wouldn't trigger any wash sale rules.

The tax-loss harvesting was implemented by selling the underperforming fixed income securities and immediately reinvesting the proceeds into similar but not identical securities to maintain the desired asset allocation. The charitable donation involved transferring ownership of $40,000 worth of highly appreciated stock directly to the Smiths’ chosen charity, a local children’s hospital.

Results & ROI

The proactive tax planning implemented by Rebecca Hayes yielded significant financial benefits for the Smiths:

• Reduced Tax Liability: The initial estimated capital gains tax liability was $85,000. Through a combination of tax-loss harvesting and charitable gifting, Rebecca reduced this liability to $35,000, resulting in a $50,000 tax savings.

• Portfolio Optimization: The tax-loss harvesting strategy allowed New Horizons to reposition the Smiths' fixed income portfolio by selling underperforming assets and reinvesting in more promising opportunities. This not only reduced their tax burden but also improved the portfolio's potential for future growth.

• Charitable Impact: The Smiths were able to make a significant contribution to their chosen charity, the local children's hospital, without incurring additional tax liabilities. This aligned their philanthropic goals with their financial planning, further strengthening their relationship with New Horizons.

• Enhanced Client Relationship: The Smiths were extremely grateful for Rebecca's proactive approach and the tangible financial benefits she delivered. This experience deepened their trust in New Horizons and solidified their long-term relationship. They expressed their satisfaction in client surveys, rating New Horizons 10/10 for financial planning services, a jump from 8/10 the previous year.

• Increased Client Retention: The successful implementation of this tax-saving strategy significantly increased the likelihood of client retention. The Smiths are now even more confident in New Horizons' ability to effectively manage their wealth and are more likely to recommend the firm to their friends and family. The lifetime value of the client, estimated at $250,000, is now more secure than ever.

Key Takeaways

1. Proactive Tax Planning is Essential: Don't wait until the end of the year to address tax planning. Implement a proactive strategy that identifies opportunities for tax savings throughout the year.

2. Utilize Tax Planning Software: Invest in professional-grade tax planning software to model different scenarios and identify potential tax-saving opportunities.

3. Collaborate with Clients' CPAs: Foster strong relationships with clients' CPAs to ensure your tax planning strategies are aligned with their overall tax situation and to navigate any potential complexities.

4. Consider Charitable Giving Strategies: Explore the potential benefits of charitable giving, such as donating appreciated securities, to help clients achieve their philanthropic goals while minimizing their tax burden.

5. Communicate Clearly and Transparently: Explain your tax planning strategies to clients in a clear and concise manner, ensuring they understand the risks and benefits involved.

About Golden Door Asset

Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors identify tax-saving opportunities, optimize portfolio allocations, and personalize client communications to strengthen relationships and drive growth. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.