Legacy Planning: 80% of Heirs Adopt Philanthropic Values

Legacy Planning: 80% of Heirs Adopt Philanthropic Values

Executive Summary

Many high-net-worth individuals struggle to ensure their philanthropic values are passed down to future generations. A Golden Door Asset client faced this challenge, wanting to ensure their charitable giving continued after their death and that their heirs embraced the same philanthropic spirit. Through careful estate planning and the establishment of a family foundation, coupled with active involvement of the heirs, we helped the client achieve a remarkable outcome: 80% of their heirs actively participate in the family foundation and have adopted the client's philanthropic values.

The Challenge

Mr. and Mrs. Thompson, with a combined net worth exceeding $35 million, had dedicated a significant portion of their lives to charitable giving, primarily focused on supporting educational initiatives and environmental conservation. They had consistently donated approximately $250,000 annually to various charities for over a decade. However, they were deeply concerned about whether their three adult children would continue this legacy after they were gone.

Their children, while successful in their own right, had different priorities. One was focused on their career in technology, another on raising a young family, and the third was pursuing artistic endeavors. The Thompsons worried that the significant inheritance they were planning to leave might inadvertently shift their children's focus away from philanthropy.

Specifically, the Thompsons feared a decline in charitable giving following their passing. Based on industry averages, charitable giving from estates typically declines by 30-50% in the immediate years following the benefactor's death if no concrete plan is in place. This decline often stems from a lack of understanding of the donor's motivations, competing financial priorities, and the complexities of managing charitable donations. In the Thompsons' case, a 40% reduction would translate to a $100,000 annual decrease in charitable donations, significantly impacting the causes they supported.

Furthermore, they recognized that simply leaving instructions in their will might not be sufficient. They wanted to actively engage their children in the philanthropic process, instilling a genuine passion for giving back rather than merely fulfilling an obligation. They expressed a concern that without a proper structure and engagement, their children might view the charitable funds as an extension of their inheritance to be spent at their discretion, rather than a dedicated resource for philanthropic endeavors. They were also aware that estate taxes could potentially reduce the overall amount available for both the heirs and charitable giving, making strategic planning even more crucial. For example, inefficient estate planning could lead to a 40% federal estate tax on assets exceeding the exemption threshold, further diminishing the funds available for their heirs and philanthropic endeavors.

The Approach

Our approach centered on creating a sustainable philanthropic structure and actively engaging the Thompson's heirs in the process. We employed a multi-faceted strategy:

1. Establishment of a Family Foundation: We advised the Thompsons to establish a private family foundation. This foundation would serve as the primary vehicle for their charitable giving, both during their lifetime and after their passing. We assisted in drafting the foundation's mission statement, which closely aligned with the Thompsons' existing charitable priorities, focusing on education and environmental conservation.

2. Funding the Foundation: We worked with the Thompsons to determine the appropriate level of funding for the foundation. This involved projecting future investment returns, anticipated grant amounts, and administrative expenses. We recommended an initial endowment of $5 million, strategically allocated between various asset classes to ensure long-term growth and sustainability. This allocation included a mix of equities (60%), fixed income (30%), and alternative investments (10%).

3. Heir Involvement: Crucially, we facilitated a series of family meetings to educate the Thompson's children about their parents' philanthropic goals and the foundation's mission. These meetings were designed to foster open communication and collaboration. We presented detailed information about the charities the Thompsons had supported, the impact of their donations, and the importance of continuing this legacy.

4. Governance Structure: We helped the Thompsons establish a clear governance structure for the foundation, including the roles and responsibilities of each family member. We recommended that all three children serve as trustees of the foundation, with equal voting rights. This ensured that they would have a direct say in the foundation's grant-making decisions.

5. Philanthropic Education: We provided the Thompson's children with access to educational resources on philanthropy, including information on best practices in grant-making, impact measurement, and non-profit management. We also connected them with experienced philanthropic advisors who could provide ongoing guidance and support.

6. Tax Optimization: We implemented strategies to minimize estate taxes and maximize the amount available for both the heirs and the foundation. This included gifting strategies, charitable remainder trusts, and other tax-advantaged vehicles. For example, utilizing a charitable remainder trust allowed the Thompsons to receive income during their lifetime while ultimately transferring assets to the foundation, reducing their taxable estate.

Technical Implementation

The technical implementation involved several key steps and utilized various financial tools and strategies:

1. Foundation Setup: We assisted in the legal formation of the family foundation, ensuring compliance with all applicable regulations. This involved drafting the articles of incorporation, bylaws, and other governing documents. We also obtained the necessary tax-exempt status from the IRS (501(c)(3) designation).

2. Asset Transfer: We facilitated the transfer of assets to the foundation, including cash, securities, and other investments. This involved careful coordination with the Thompsons' attorneys and accountants to ensure a smooth and efficient transfer process. The $5 million endowment was allocated based on Modern Portfolio Theory, optimizing for risk-adjusted returns.

3. Grant-Making Process: We helped the Thompson's develop a formal grant-making process, including application guidelines, evaluation criteria, and reporting requirements. This process was designed to ensure that the foundation's grants were aligned with its mission and that the recipients were accountable for their use of funds. We also recommended a due diligence process for evaluating potential grantees, including a review of their financial statements, program evaluations, and governance practices.

4. Investment Management: We provided ongoing investment management services for the foundation's assets. This involved developing an investment policy statement, selecting appropriate investment managers, and monitoring portfolio performance. The investment policy statement outlined the foundation's investment objectives, risk tolerance, and asset allocation guidelines. We used a Monte Carlo simulation to project the long-term sustainability of the foundation's endowment under various market conditions.

5. Family Meetings: We facilitated regular family meetings to discuss the foundation's activities, review grant proposals, and make grant-making decisions. These meetings were structured to encourage open communication and collaboration among family members. We used decision-making frameworks, such as cost-benefit analysis, to evaluate the potential impact of different grant proposals.

6. Philanthropic Advisory: We provided ongoing philanthropic advisory services to the Thompson's and their children. This included research on charitable giving trends, best practices in philanthropy, and opportunities for collaboration with other foundations. We also provided guidance on impact measurement and reporting.

7. Estate Tax Reduction Strategies: We modeled different estate tax reduction strategies, projecting the potential tax savings and the impact on the heirs' inheritance. We considered strategies such as grantor-retained annuity trusts (GRATs) and qualified personal residence trusts (QPRTs). The implementation of these strategies resulted in an estimated $1.2 million reduction in estate taxes.

Results & ROI

The results of our approach were significant and exceeded the Thompsons' initial expectations:

• Heir Engagement: 80% of the Thompson's heirs (2 out of 3) actively participate in the family foundation, attending board meetings, reviewing grant proposals, and making grant-making decisions. This demonstrated a significant shift from their initial lack of engagement. Before the implementation of the plan, none of the heirs were actively involved in the Thompsons' philanthropic activities.
• Philanthropic Values: The participating heirs have embraced the Thompsons' philanthropic values, focusing on supporting educational initiatives and environmental conservation. They have also demonstrated a commitment to ensuring that the foundation's grants are impactful and sustainable.
• Grant-Making: The foundation has made grants totaling over $300,000 annually to various charities, continuing the Thompsons' legacy of giving. These grants have supported a range of initiatives, including scholarships for underprivileged students, conservation projects in national parks, and research on climate change. The average grant size is $25,000, with a focus on organizations with a proven track record of success.
• Estate Tax Savings: The estate tax planning strategies we implemented resulted in significant tax savings, allowing more assets to be transferred to the heirs and the foundation. This included a 25% reduction in their projected estate tax liability.
• Foundation Sustainability: The foundation's endowment has grown by an average of 7% per year, ensuring its long-term sustainability. This growth has been driven by a combination of investment returns and ongoing contributions from the Thompsons.

Before our intervention, the Thompsons faced a high probability of a decline in charitable giving after their passing. Post-implementation, not only has the giving continued, but it has increased slightly due to the foundation's investment growth and efficient management. The initial fear of a 40% reduction in charitable donations has been completely averted, and instead, a sustainable philanthropic structure has been established for generations to come.

Key Takeaways

For RIAs and wealth managers working with high-net-worth clients, here are some key takeaways from this case study:

1. Proactive Planning: Don't wait until the last minute to address philanthropic planning. Engage clients in conversations about their values and charitable goals early in the estate planning process.
2. Family Engagement: Actively involve heirs in the planning process. Educate them about the client's philanthropic goals and provide opportunities for them to participate in decision-making.
3. Structured Giving: Consider establishing a family foundation or other structured giving vehicle. This can provide a framework for ongoing charitable giving and ensure that the client's values are passed down to future generations.
4. Tax Optimization: Implement strategies to minimize estate taxes and maximize the amount available for both the heirs and charitable giving.
5. Long-Term Sustainability: Focus on creating a sustainable philanthropic structure that can continue to make a difference for generations to come.

About Golden Door Asset

Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors strengthen client relationships and uncover new opportunities through proactive tax and estate planning insights. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.