Enhanced Suitability Reviews Boost Client Retention to 98%

Enhanced Suitability Reviews Boost Client Retention to 98%

Executive Summary

Rossi Family Office, managing over $300 million in assets, struggled to maintain consistently high client retention rates due to evolving client needs and increasing regulatory scrutiny. Golden Door Asset implemented a refined suitability review process leveraging Riskalyze and CRM integration, ensuring investment recommendations were meticulously aligned with client risk profiles and financial goals. The enhanced process demonstrably improved client satisfaction, resulting in a significant boost in client retention to an impressive 98%, while mitigating potential compliance risks.

The Challenge

Rossi Family Office prided itself on delivering personalized wealth management services to high-net-worth families. However, in recent years, they faced growing challenges in maintaining optimal client retention. Their previous suitability review process, while compliant, was somewhat reactive and relied heavily on manual assessments. This created several pain points:

• Evolving Client Needs: Clients’ financial goals, risk tolerances, and life circumstances often changed more rapidly than their portfolio allocations reflected. For example, a 60-year-old client initially comfortable with a 70/30 stock/bond allocation might become significantly more risk-averse as they approached retirement, needing a portfolio adjustment that wasn’t proactively identified. Leaving clients with mismatched recommendations ran the risk of damaging the relationship, and opened them up to leaving the firm.

• Increased Regulatory Scrutiny: The regulatory landscape surrounding suitability requirements was becoming increasingly stringent. Failing to demonstrate a clear and documented alignment between investment recommendations and client profiles exposed Rossi Family Office to potential compliance violations and reputational damage. One specific area of concern was Reg BI (Regulation Best Interest), which required them to act in the best interest of their clients when making recommendations. Their existing process lacked the granular documentation and proactive review necessary to confidently demonstrate compliance.

• Retention Concerns: Client attrition was costing the firm significant revenue and resources. With an average client relationship value of $5,000 per year, even a small decrease in retention translated to substantial financial losses. Specifically, in the year prior to engaging with Golden Door Asset, their client retention rate dipped to 92%, resulting in an estimated $150,000 in lost revenue due to client departures. Furthermore, acquiring new clients to replace those lost was time-consuming and expensive, averaging approximately $2,500 per new client acquisition.

• Inconsistent Suitability: Due to the manual and subjective nature of the existing suitability review process, there were inconsistencies in how different advisors at the firm assessed client risk and aligned investment recommendations. This led to situations where clients with similar profiles received varying advice, potentially causing confusion and dissatisfaction. For instance, two clients, both with similar net worths of $2 million, one showed 1% more risk tolerance than the other. The problem became, if the advisor treated them exactly the same, it could violate the principles of Reg BI, and negatively affect the clients portfolio.

Rossi Family Office recognized the urgent need to enhance its suitability review process to better understand and address evolving client needs, mitigate regulatory risks, and ultimately improve client retention.

The Approach

Golden Door Asset collaborated with Rossi Family Office to implement a systematic and data-driven approach to suitability reviews, built on three core principles:

1. Quantifiable Risk Assessment: We replaced the subjective assessment of risk tolerance with a quantifiable methodology using Riskalyze. This allowed us to objectively measure each client’s willingness and ability to take risk, generating a Risk Number that served as the foundation for investment recommendations.

2. Holistic Client View: We integrated Riskalyze with Rossi Family Office’s existing CRM system. This created a centralized platform that provided advisors with a comprehensive view of each client, including their financial goals, risk profile, investment history, and personal circumstances. This holistic view enabled advisors to make more informed and personalized investment recommendations.

3. Proactive Monitoring and Documentation: We established a proactive monitoring system to identify clients whose risk profiles or financial goals had changed significantly. This triggered a suitability review to ensure their investment recommendations remained aligned with their current needs. All suitability assessments were meticulously documented, providing a clear audit trail for compliance purposes.

Detailed Methodology:

• Initial Risk Assessment: Each client completed a Riskalyze questionnaire to determine their Risk Number. This assessment considered factors such as their investment time horizon, financial goals, and comfort level with market volatility. We explained the tool to each client in detail, and worked to answer any questions they had.

• Investment Policy Statement (IPS) Alignment: The client's Risk Number was then compared against the risk profile of their existing investment portfolio. Any significant discrepancies triggered a review of the client's Investment Policy Statement (IPS). If the IPS was outdated or did not accurately reflect the client's current needs, it was revised in collaboration with the client.

• Investment Recommendation Review: All investment recommendations were evaluated to ensure they aligned with the client's Risk Number and IPS. We used Riskalyze’s Portfolio Analysis tool to quantify the risk of each proposed investment and demonstrate its suitability to the client.

• CRM Integration: The Riskalyze data was seamlessly integrated with the CRM system, providing advisors with real-time access to client risk profiles and suitability assessments. This allowed advisors to quickly and easily identify potential suitability issues and address them proactively.

• Regular Monitoring: We established a system for regularly monitoring client risk profiles for significant changes. This included tracking changes in their Risk Number, financial goals, and personal circumstances. Any significant change triggered a suitability review to ensure their investment recommendations remained aligned with their current needs.

This structured approach ensured that all investment recommendations were grounded in objective data, aligned with client needs, and thoroughly documented.

Technical Implementation

The technical implementation involved several key components and integrations:

• Riskalyze Integration: Rossi Family Office adopted Riskalyze as their primary risk assessment tool. They leveraged Riskalyze’s API to seamlessly integrate the tool with their existing CRM (Salesforce). This integration allowed advisors to access client Risk Numbers and portfolio risk scores directly from the CRM interface. We also created custom dashboards in Riskalyze to monitor the overall risk profile of the firm’s client base and identify potential suitability issues.

• CRM Customization: The CRM system was customized to include fields for storing client Risk Numbers, IPS details, and suitability assessment documentation. We also implemented automated workflows to trigger suitability reviews based on predefined criteria, such as changes in client risk tolerance or financial goals.

• Data Security: We implemented strict data security protocols to ensure the confidentiality and integrity of client data. This included encryption of data in transit and at rest, as well as regular security audits and vulnerability assessments. Rossi Family Office also updated their compliance manual with specific guidance on data security and privacy.

• Investment Platform Integration: A direct connection was established to their existing brokerage platform, Pershing, allowing risk scores and portfolio metrics to be displayed in the advisor portal. This eliminated the need for manual entry, reducing errors and improving advisor efficiency.

• Report Generation: Automated report generation was implemented so advisors could pull reports to show to their clients, demonstrating the work they had done to ensure recommendations were best suited for their goals.

Key Calculations & Methodologies:

• Risk Number Calculation: Riskalyze uses a proprietary algorithm to calculate the Risk Number based on client responses to a questionnaire. The algorithm considers factors such as their investment time horizon, financial goals, and comfort level with market volatility. The Risk Number is a single, quantifiable measure of their risk tolerance, ranging from 1 to 99, with higher numbers indicating a greater willingness to take risk.

• Portfolio Risk Score Calculation: Riskalyze also calculates a risk score for each client portfolio, based on the volatility and correlation of the underlying investments. This score is then compared to the client's Risk Number to assess the suitability of the portfolio.

• Sharpe Ratio Analysis: We used Sharpe Ratio analysis to evaluate the risk-adjusted returns of different investment options. This allowed us to identify investments that provided the best potential return for a given level of risk, and ensure that recommendations were aligned with the client's risk tolerance.

Results & ROI

The implementation of the enhanced suitability review process yielded significant positive results for Rossi Family Office:

• Client Retention: Client retention rates improved from 92% to 98% within one year, representing a 6% increase. This translated to an estimated $300,000 in additional revenue per year, based on an average client relationship value of $5,000 per year.

• Reduced Compliance Risk: The documented suitability assessments provided a clear audit trail for compliance purposes, significantly reducing the risk of regulatory violations and reputational damage. Previously, compliance audits took an average of 40 hours to complete per advisor, but this was reduced to 15 hours per advisor after implementing the automated system.

• Improved Client Satisfaction: Clients reported a greater sense of confidence in their investment recommendations, knowing that they were aligned with their individual risk profiles and financial goals. Client satisfaction scores, measured through post-meeting surveys, increased from an average of 8.5 to 9.3 out of 10.

• Increased Advisor Efficiency: The integration of Riskalyze and the CRM system streamlined the suitability review process, freeing up advisors to spend more time on client relationship management and business development. Advisors reported a 15% reduction in the time spent on administrative tasks related to suitability assessments.

• Increased AUM: Client conversations and confidence, paired with suitability, resulted in additional assets under management of 15 million dollars in the same year.

Detailed ROI Breakdown:

• Increased Revenue from Retention: (6% increase in retention) * (Number of clients) * (Average client relationship value) = (0.06) * (1000) * ($5,000) = $300,000
• Cost Savings from Reduced Compliance Time: (25 hours saved per advisor per audit) * (Number of advisors) * (Hourly rate of compliance staff) = (25) * (5) * ($75) = $9,375

Key Takeaways

1. Quantify Risk Tolerance: Moving beyond subjective assessments to quantifiable risk profiling using tools like Riskalyze is crucial for ensuring suitability.

2. Integrate Data for a Holistic View: Integrating risk assessment data with CRM systems provides advisors with a comprehensive view of each client, enabling more informed and personalized recommendations.

3. Proactive Monitoring is Essential: Implement a system for regularly monitoring client risk profiles and financial goals to identify potential suitability issues before they impact client satisfaction or compliance.

4. Document Everything: Meticulous documentation of all suitability assessments provides a clear audit trail for compliance purposes and protects the firm from potential regulatory scrutiny.

5. Client Communication is Key: Open and transparent communication with clients about the suitability review process builds trust and enhances client satisfaction.

About Golden Door Asset

Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors increase AUM by leveraging the latest AI powered solutions to make your work more efficient and effective. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.