Estate Tax Reduction: Charitable Remainder Trust Creation

Estate Tax Reduction: Charitable Remainder Trust Creation

Executive Summary

Facing a substantial estate tax liability, a high-net-worth client sought a strategy to reduce their tax burden while simultaneously supporting their lifelong passion: local animal welfare. Harrington Legacy Advisors, in partnership with Golden Door Asset, crafted a Charitable Remainder Trust (CRT) strategy. This approach allowed the client to donate appreciated assets to the trust, receive a stream of income for a defined period, and ultimately benefit the local animal shelter, resulting in an estimated $750,000 reduction in estate tax liability and ongoing income for the client.

The Challenge

Mr. and Mrs. Thompson, successful entrepreneurs nearing retirement, approached Harrington Legacy Advisors with a pressing concern: their estate was valued at approximately $15 million, placing them well within the federal estate tax threshold. They were deeply committed to supporting "Happy Paws Haven," a local animal shelter that had rescued and rehomed countless animals over the years. Mr. and Mrs. Thompson wanted to make a significant charitable contribution to Happy Paws Haven, but were also acutely aware of the impending estate tax burden.

Specifically, their CPA estimated that without proactive planning, their estate would face a federal estate tax liability exceeding $900,000. A substantial portion of their wealth was tied up in highly appreciated stock valued at $4 million, acquired many years ago for a cost basis of just $200,000. Selling these stocks outright would trigger a significant capital gains tax, further diminishing the amount available for both their retirement and their charitable giving goals. They were facing a difficult choice: reduce their estate tax liability, provide ongoing support to their charity of choice, or maximize their retirement income – potentially having to sacrifice one goal in favor of another. They were seeking a solution that would address all three objectives. The projected Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) from their existing retirement accounts were also a concern, as they were poised to push them into a higher tax bracket during their retirement years.

The Approach

Harrington Legacy Advisors, leveraging analytical tools and insights powered by Golden Door Asset, recommended the creation of a Charitable Remainder Trust (CRT). This strategy aligned perfectly with the Thompsons’ objectives by offering a trifecta of benefits: estate tax reduction, ongoing income generation, and significant charitable giving.

Our recommended approach involved the following steps:

1. Comprehensive Estate Planning Review: We conducted a thorough review of the Thompsons’ existing estate plan, including wills, trusts, and power of attorney documents. This allowed us to identify potential areas for optimization and ensure that the CRT strategy seamlessly integrated with their overall estate planning objectives.

2. Charitable Remainder Trust (CRT) Design: We designed a CRT tailored to the Thompsons’ specific financial circumstances and charitable giving goals. We opted for a Charitable Remainder Annuity Trust (CRAT), providing a fixed annual payment to the Thompsons for a specified term of 20 years. This fixed payment offered predictability and security, addressing their concerns about retirement income. The annuity amount was calculated to be 5% of the initial fair market value of the assets contributed to the trust, resulting in an annual income stream of $200,000.

3. Asset Selection and Transfer: We identified the highly appreciated stock as the ideal asset to transfer to the CRT. Transferring the stock directly to the CRT allowed the Thompsons to avoid incurring capital gains taxes on the appreciation. This was a crucial element of the strategy, as it preserved a significant portion of the asset value for both their income stream and the ultimate charitable donation.

4. Collaboration with Legal and Tax Professionals: We collaborated closely with the Thompsons’ estate planning attorney and tax advisor to ensure that the CRT was structured in full compliance with IRS regulations and maximized the tax benefits. This collaboration was essential to avoid any potential pitfalls and ensure the long-term effectiveness of the strategy.

5. Ongoing Trust Management: We provided ongoing management of the CRT, including investment management, tax reporting, and distribution administration. This ensured that the trust continued to operate smoothly and effectively, providing the Thompsons with the income they needed and fulfilling their charitable giving goals.

The Golden Door Asset platform was instrumental in projecting the long-term financial impact of the CRT, allowing us to demonstrate the benefits to the Thompsons with clear and compelling data visualizations. We used the platform to model various scenarios, adjusting the annuity rate, the term of the trust, and the expected rate of return on the trust assets to optimize the strategy for their specific needs.

Technical Implementation

The technical implementation of the CRT involved several key steps:

1. Trust Document Creation: Working with the Thompsons' attorney, we drafted a comprehensive trust document that adhered strictly to IRS regulations for Charitable Remainder Annuity Trusts. This included specifying the annuity amount (5% of the initial fair market value), the term of the trust (20 years), and the designated charitable beneficiary (Happy Paws Haven).

2. Asset Transfer and Valuation: We facilitated the transfer of $4 million in appreciated stock to the newly formed CRT. A qualified appraiser was engaged to determine the fair market value of the stock at the time of the transfer. This valuation was critical for calculating the charitable income tax deduction and the annuity payment.

3. Tax Filing and Reporting: We prepared all necessary tax forms related to the CRT, including Form 5227 (Split-Interest Trust Information Return) and Form 1041-A (U.S. Information Return – Trust Accumulation of Charitable Amounts). We also provided the Thompsons with the information needed to claim the charitable income tax deduction on their personal tax return.

4. Investment Management: The CRT assets were invested in a diversified portfolio of stocks and bonds, designed to generate a consistent income stream while preserving the principal value. The portfolio allocation was carefully selected to balance risk and return, taking into account the Thompsons’ risk tolerance and the long-term needs of the trust. The initial allocation was 60% equities and 40% fixed income.

5. Annuity Payment Administration: We established a system for making regular annuity payments to the Thompsons, ensuring that payments were made on time and in the correct amount. We also tracked the total amount of annuity payments made over the term of the trust. The $200,000 annual payment was structured as quarterly installments of $50,000.

The present value of the remainder interest passing to Happy Paws Haven was calculated using IRS tables and a discount rate based on the applicable federal rate (AFR) at the time of the contribution. This calculation determined the amount of the charitable income tax deduction available to the Thompsons. The specific AFR used was 2.0%, resulting in a significant charitable deduction.

Results & ROI

The implementation of the Charitable Remainder Trust yielded significant financial benefits for the Thompsons and Happy Paws Haven:

• Estate Tax Reduction: The CRT effectively removed $4 million from the Thompsons’ taxable estate, resulting in an estimated estate tax savings of $750,000. This was calculated by multiplying the $4 million reduction in estate value by the federal estate tax rate of 40% less the deduction in income taxes from the charitable contribution.

• Capital Gains Tax Avoidance: By donating the appreciated stock directly to the CRT, the Thompsons avoided paying capital gains taxes on the $3.8 million gain. This represented a tax savings of approximately $950,000 (assuming a combined federal and state capital gains tax rate of 25%).

• Ongoing Income Stream: The CRT provided the Thompsons with a fixed annual income of $200,000 for 20 years, supplementing their retirement income. This provided them with financial security and allowed them to maintain their lifestyle comfortably.

• Charitable Contribution: At the end of the 20-year term, the remaining assets in the CRT will pass to Happy Paws Haven, providing them with a substantial endowment to support their ongoing operations. The projected value of the remainder interest at the end of the term, assuming a conservative average annual growth rate of 5%, is estimated to be over $5.3 million.

• Income Tax Deduction: The Thompsons received a significant charitable income tax deduction in the year they established the CRT, further reducing their overall tax burden. The deduction was calculated based on the present value of the remainder interest passing to Happy Paws Haven.

Key Takeaways

For other advisors considering a CRT strategy:

1. Assess the Client's Charitable Intent: Ensure that the client has a genuine desire to support a charitable organization. A CRT is not solely a tax-avoidance strategy; it is a vehicle for charitable giving.
2. Consider Appreciated Assets: CRTs are particularly effective for clients holding highly appreciated assets, as they allow them to avoid capital gains taxes.
3. Collaborate with Experts: Partner with estate planning attorneys and tax advisors to ensure that the CRT is structured correctly and complies with all applicable regulations.
4. Model Various Scenarios: Use financial planning software to model different scenarios and illustrate the potential benefits of the CRT to the client. Demonstrate the impact on their estate tax liability, income stream, and charitable giving goals.
5. Communicate Clearly: Explain the complexities of the CRT to the client in a clear and concise manner. Make sure they understand the terms of the trust and the implications for their financial situation.

About Golden Door Asset

Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors uncover hidden opportunities, deliver hyper-personalized advice, and improve client outcomes. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.