Personalized Videos: Whitfield Sees 12% Higher Client Engagement

Personalized Videos: Whitfield Sees 12% Higher Client Engagement

Executive Summary

Whitfield Tax, a leading tax advisory firm, faced challenges in engaging clients with traditional email communication, resulting in low open rates and limited interaction with crucial financial updates. To address this, Whitfield implemented personalized video messages for client onboarding, quarterly updates, and significant announcements. This approach fostered a more personal connection, leading to a remarkable 12% increase in client engagement, measured by click-through rates and response rates to follow-up actions.

The Challenge

Whitfield Tax prides itself on providing highly personalized tax planning and advisory services. However, scaling this personalized touch across a growing client base presented a significant challenge. Traditional email communication, while necessary for distributing financial updates and tax strategies, was proving increasingly ineffective.

Specifically, Whitfield found that their average email open rate for quarterly investment performance reports hovered around 28%. This meant that over 70% of their clients weren't actively engaging with critical information about their financial well-being. Consider a client like Mrs. Johnson, whose portfolio Whitfield manages. While Mrs. Johnson is invested in a diversified portfolio with a goal of 7% annual returns, if she consistently misses quarterly updates, she might become anxious during market fluctuations and make rash decisions based on incomplete information. This not only puts her financial goals at risk but also increases the likelihood of client churn for Whitfield.

Furthermore, Whitfield noticed a disconnect between the complexity of their tax strategies and the clients' understanding of these strategies. For instance, implementing a sophisticated tax-loss harvesting strategy saved a client, Mr. Davis, approximately $8,000 in taxes. However, because Mr. Davis didn't fully understand the strategy's mechanics through static email explanations, he expressed hesitation and required multiple follow-up calls to fully grasp the benefits. This resulted in significant time investment from Whitfield's team and highlighted the need for a more effective communication method to ensure clients not only received but also understood and appreciated the value of the services being provided. The impersonal nature of email also led to fewer clients proactively scheduling annual planning meetings, impacting Whitfield’s ability to offer customized strategies aligned with their evolving financial goals. Before implementing personalized videos, only 45% of clients proactively scheduled their annual planning meeting. This shortfall resulted in lost opportunities to proactively identify potential tax benefits and investment opportunities, potentially costing clients thousands of dollars in missed savings and growth.

The Approach

Whitfield Tax recognized the need to move beyond generic email communication and embrace a more engaging and personalized approach. They decided to implement personalized video messages as a key component of their client communication strategy. The approach involved the following steps:

1. Identifying Key Communication Opportunities: Whitfield identified three primary areas where personalized videos could have the most significant impact:

• Client Onboarding: Welcoming new clients with a personalized video message to build rapport and establish a strong relationship from the outset.
• Quarterly Updates: Providing concise and engaging video summaries of client portfolio performance, market trends, and tax planning strategies.
• Special Announcements: Communicating important news, such as changes in tax laws or new investment opportunities, in a clear and easily understandable format.

2. Script Development and Personalization: For each communication opportunity, Whitfield developed templates for video scripts. These scripts included placeholders for personalization, such as the client's name, investment goals, and specific portfolio details. For example, in a quarterly update video, the advisor would specifically mention Mrs. Johnson’s recent gains in her technology sector holdings or highlight Mr. Davis’ utilization of tax-loss harvesting benefits.

3. Video Recording and Editing: Whitfield utilized Loom, a user-friendly video recording platform, to create the personalized video messages. Advisors were trained on how to deliver concise, engaging presentations that clearly explained complex financial concepts. They also focused on maintaining a warm and approachable demeanor to build trust and connection with clients. Editing was kept to a minimum to maintain a natural and authentic feel.

4. Integration with CRM: To streamline the process, Whitfield integrated Loom with their CRM system (ActiveCampaign). This integration allowed them to automatically generate personalized video messages for specific client segments and trigger automated email campaigns that included the video link. The CRM also captured engagement data, such as click-through rates and video completion rates, which was crucial for measuring the effectiveness of the approach.

5. Client Education: Whitfield proactively educated clients about the new video communication strategy, explaining the benefits of receiving personalized updates and encouraging them to engage with the content. They even created a short introductory video explaining how to access and view the videos.

Technical Implementation

The implementation of personalized video communication required a careful integration of technology and a commitment to data-driven decision-making.

1. Technology Stack:

• Loom: Utilized for recording and hosting personalized video messages. Loom's screen recording and webcam capabilities enabled advisors to easily create engaging videos that combined visual explanations with personal interaction.
• ActiveCampaign: Served as the CRM and email marketing platform. ActiveCampaign's automation features allowed Whitfield to segment clients, personalize video links, and trigger email campaigns based on specific client characteristics and behaviors.
• API Integration: A custom API integration was developed to seamlessly connect Loom and ActiveCampaign. This integration automatically generated personalized video links based on client data in ActiveCampaign and inserted these links into the corresponding email templates.

2. Personalization Logic:

The personalization logic within ActiveCampaign was based on a combination of client data and behavioral triggers. For example:

• Client Onboarding: When a new client was added to ActiveCampaign, the system automatically generated a personalized welcome video featuring the advisor and outlining the onboarding process.
• Quarterly Updates: ActiveCampaign pulled data from the firm’s portfolio management system on each client's portfolio performance and key metrics. This data was dynamically inserted into the video script, allowing the advisor to provide a highly personalized update.
• Special Announcements: The system used client segmentation to target specific groups based on their investment goals, risk tolerance, and tax bracket. This ensured that clients received only relevant announcements.

3. Performance Tracking:

ActiveCampaign's tracking capabilities provided valuable insights into the effectiveness of the video communication strategy. Key metrics included:

• Click-Through Rates (CTR): Measured the percentage of clients who clicked on the video link in the email.
• Video Completion Rates: Tracked how much of each video clients watched.
• Response Rates: Monitored the number of clients who responded to the video message, either by scheduling a follow-up call or sending an email.
• Website Engagement: Tracked client website activity after viewing the video, such as visiting specific pages related to tax planning or investment strategies.

4. Calculation of Engagement Increase:

Client engagement increase was calculated based on a composite score that considers click-through rates, video completion rates, and response rates. The baseline engagement score was established based on the 3-month period before the implementation of personalized videos. The calculation is as follows:

• Engagement Score = (CTR Weighting * CTR) + (Completion Rate Weighting * Completion Rate) + (Response Rate Weighting * Response Rate)
  • Where CTR Weighting = 0.4, Completion Rate Weighting = 0.3, Response Rate Weighting = 0.3

Results & ROI

The implementation of personalized video messages yielded significant positive results for Whitfield Tax.

• Overall Client Engagement Increase: As previously stated, client engagement, as measured by the composite engagement score, increased by 12% within the first quarter of implementation. This improvement demonstrates the effectiveness of video in capturing and maintaining client attention.
• Email Open Rate Improvement: Email open rates for quarterly investment reports increased from 28% to 42%, a 50% improvement. This meant that more clients were actively reviewing critical information about their financial portfolios.
• Response Rate Surge: The response rate to follow-up actions, such as scheduling annual planning meetings, increased by 18%. Clients were more likely to take the next step after engaging with the personalized video message. This lead to an additional 35 booked annual planning meetings in the first quarter.
• Increased Client Understanding: Anecdotally, advisors reported a noticeable improvement in client understanding of complex financial concepts. Clients asked more informed questions and expressed greater confidence in the strategies being implemented. This resulted in fewer follow-up calls and a more efficient use of advisor time.
• Client Retention Boost: While quantifying the exact impact on client retention is an ongoing process, Whitfield observed a decrease in client churn during the first quarter after implementation. This suggests that personalized videos contribute to stronger client relationships and increased loyalty.
• Time Savings: Although the videos require initial creation time, the reduced number of follow-up calls and more productive client meetings resulted in an estimated 15% reduction in time spent per client per quarter.

Financial Impact: The 12% increase in client engagement, combined with the increased efficiency and improved client retention, is projected to generate an additional $50,000 in revenue for Whitfield Tax within the first year. This figure considers the increased sales opportunities during annual planning meetings and reduced churn.

Key Takeaways

1. Personalization is paramount: Clients value personalized communication that demonstrates a genuine understanding of their individual needs and goals. Generic emails are no longer sufficient to capture their attention and build trust.
2. Video is a powerful engagement tool: Video messages offer a more engaging and impactful way to communicate complex financial concepts than traditional text-based emails. Visual explanations and personal interaction can significantly improve client understanding and retention.
3. Integration is key: Seamlessly integrating video communication into your existing CRM and email marketing workflows is essential for maximizing efficiency and scalability. Automate the process of generating personalized video links and triggering email campaigns.
4. Track and measure your results: Monitor key metrics, such as click-through rates, video completion rates, and response rates, to assess the effectiveness of your video communication strategy and identify areas for improvement.
5. Client education is crucial: Proactively educate clients about the benefits of your video communication strategy and encourage them to engage with the content. This will help ensure that they understand the value of your services and are more likely to take the desired actions.

About Golden Door Asset

Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors personalize client experiences at scale, enhance client loyalty and reduce attrition. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.