Santos Financial Reduces Social Media Risk by 60%

Santos Financial Reduces Social Media Risk by 60%

Executive Summary

Santos Financial, a growing RIA with $750 million AUM, faced a significant challenge: unmonitored employee social media activity posed a severe compliance risk, threatening potential regulatory violations and reputational damage. Golden Door Asset helped Santos Financial develop a comprehensive social media policy, implement robust monitoring tools, and provide engaging employee training. The result? A 60% reduction in identified social media compliance risks and greater peace of mind for the firm's leadership.

The Challenge

In today's digital age, social media is a powerful tool for connecting with clients and prospects. However, for Registered Investment Advisors (RIAs) like Santos Financial, it also presents a significant compliance minefield. While Santos Financial encouraged their 15 advisors to engage online, they lacked a robust system for monitoring and controlling the content shared. This exposed them to several critical risks:

• Advertising Rule Violations: The SEC's advertising rule 206(4)-1, commonly known as the Advertising Rule, prohibits materially misleading statements or omissions in advertisements. Unapproved posts promoting specific investment products or guaranteeing returns could trigger violations, potentially leading to hefty fines. Santos Financial estimated a single violation could cost them between $50,000 and $250,000 in fines, depending on the severity and frequency.
• Testimonial and Endorsement Concerns: Without proper oversight, advisors might inadvertently solicit or share testimonials without the required disclosures, creating compliance issues under SEC Rule 206(4)-1(b) which applies to endorsements and testimonials.
• Confidential Information Leaks: Employees might unintentionally disclose non-public client information (NPPI), violating privacy regulations and exposing the firm to potential lawsuits. Imagine an advisor mentioning a client's recent investment in a blog post without proper anonymization – a clear violation.
• Brand Damage: Inappropriate or offensive content shared by employees, even on personal accounts, could reflect poorly on Santos Financial, damaging their reputation and eroding client trust. A poorly worded tweet or a controversial post could lead to a loss of clients, estimated to be around 5% of AUM, representing a loss of $37.5 million if confidence eroded.
• Lack of Documentation: Without a clear social media policy and monitoring system, Santos Financial struggled to demonstrate compliance to regulators during audits. This lack of documented oversight increased their vulnerability and could result in enhanced scrutiny. The firm spent approximately 40 hours per month manually reviewing social media posts, a time-consuming and inefficient process. This translates to approximately $4,000 in employee time per month (assuming an hourly rate of $100).

Santos Financial recognized that their existing approach – relying on advisors to self-regulate and infrequent spot checks – was inadequate. They needed a comprehensive solution to mitigate these risks and ensure compliance with regulatory requirements. They believed a proactive approach was crucial to avoiding costly fines and reputational damage.

The Approach

Golden Door Asset worked closely with Santos Financial to develop and implement a multi-faceted approach to address their social media compliance challenges:

1. Risk Assessment: The first step involved a thorough risk assessment to identify the specific areas of vulnerability. We reviewed Santos Financial's existing policies (or lack thereof), interviewed key stakeholders, and analyzed typical social media usage patterns among their advisors. This assessment pinpointed the need for a comprehensive social media policy, proactive monitoring, and targeted employee training.

2. Social Media Policy Development: We drafted a comprehensive social media policy tailored to Santos Financial's specific needs and regulatory requirements. This policy included clear guidelines on:

   • Permissible Content: Defining the types of content advisors could share, emphasizing investment-related topics and avoiding misleading statements.
   • Prohibited Content: Outlining content that was strictly prohibited, including specific product recommendations, guarantees of returns, and confidential client information.
   • Disclosure Requirements: Detailing the necessary disclosures for any investment-related posts, ensuring compliance with advertising rules.
   • Personal vs. Professional Use: Clearly distinguishing between personal and professional social media activity, emphasizing the need for responsible conduct even on personal accounts.
   • Content Approval Process: Establishing a process for pre-approval of all investment-related content before it was published online, including templates for frequently used social media posts.

3. Technology Implementation: Golden Door Asset recommended and assisted in the implementation of Hearsay Systems, a leading social media monitoring and compliance platform. This platform provided several key features:

   • Content Monitoring: Automated monitoring of all employee social media activity across various platforms, including LinkedIn, Twitter, and Facebook.
   • Keyword Alerts: Real-time alerts for any posts containing keywords or phrases that could indicate potential compliance issues, such as "guaranteed returns" or "high-yield investments."
   • Content Approval Workflow: A streamlined workflow for submitting content for pre-approval, ensuring compliance with the firm's social media policy.
   • Archiving and Audit Trails: Comprehensive archiving of all social media activity, providing a clear audit trail for regulatory compliance.
   • Integration with existing CRM: Connecting Hearsay to Santos Financial's client relationship management (CRM) system provided additional context and insights for compliance reviews.

4. Employee Training: Recognizing that technology alone was not enough, we developed and delivered engaging employee training modules on compliant social media usage. These modules covered:

   • The Importance of Compliance: Emphasizing the potential consequences of non-compliance, including fines, reputational damage, and regulatory sanctions.
   • Social Media Policy Overview: Providing a detailed explanation of the firm's social media policy and its key requirements.
   • Best Practices for Compliant Content Creation: Offering practical tips and examples for creating engaging and compliant social media content.
   • Hands-on Exercises: Providing opportunities for advisors to practice creating and submitting content for approval.
   • Regular Refresher Courses: Ensuring ongoing compliance through regular refresher courses and updates on regulatory changes.

5. Ongoing Monitoring and Support: Golden Door Asset provided ongoing monitoring and support to ensure the effectiveness of the program. This included regular compliance reviews, updates to the social media policy as needed, and assistance with regulatory inquiries.

Technical Implementation

The technical implementation centered around the integration and utilization of Hearsay Systems:

• Platform Setup and Configuration: Golden Door Asset assisted Santos Financial in setting up and configuring Hearsay Systems to align with their specific needs and compliance requirements. This included defining monitoring parameters, setting up keyword alerts, and customizing the content approval workflow.
• Data Integration: We integrated Hearsay Systems with Santos Financial's CRM system, allowing for a more holistic view of client interactions and enhancing compliance reviews.
• Automated Reporting: Hearsay Systems was configured to generate automated reports on social media activity, providing real-time insights into compliance risks and overall social media performance.
• API Integration: Leveraging Hearsay's API, we developed custom dashboards to visualize compliance metrics and track the effectiveness of the social media policy.
• Calculation of Risk Reduction: Risk reduction was calculated by tracking the number of potential compliance violations identified by Hearsay Systems before and after implementation. Before implementing the solution, a manual review of approximately 100 posts per month revealed an average of 10 potential violations related to advertising rules, undisclosed testimonials, or improper disclosures. After implementation, the number of potential violations identified by Hearsay Systems and flagged for review decreased to an average of 4 per month. This represents a 60% reduction in identified risks.

Results & ROI

The implementation of Golden Door Asset's social media compliance solution delivered significant results for Santos Financial:

• 60% Reduction in Social Media Compliance Risk: As measured by the number of potential violations identified through monitoring, Santos Financial achieved a 60% reduction in social media compliance risk.
• Significant Time Savings: By automating social media monitoring and content approval, Santos Financial reduced the time spent on manual reviews by 75%, freeing up valuable resources for other tasks. The 40 hours of manual review required was reduced to only 10 hours.
• Enhanced Regulatory Compliance: Santos Financial was now able to demonstrate a proactive approach to social media compliance, reducing their vulnerability to regulatory scrutiny. The firm also successfully passed an SEC compliance audit, with no findings related to social media usage.
• Improved Brand Reputation: By ensuring that all social media content was compliant and consistent with the firm's brand values, Santos Financial strengthened their reputation and built trust with clients and prospects. They noticed a 15% increase in positive mentions on social media.
• Reduced Potential for Fines and Penalties: By proactively mitigating social media compliance risks, Santos Financial significantly reduced their potential for regulatory fines and penalties, potentially saving them tens of thousands of dollars. By avoiding just one potential violation that would result in a $50,000 fine, the firm has easily paid for the annual cost of the Hearsay Systems platform.
• Increased Employee Confidence: Advisors felt more confident engaging on social media, knowing that their content was compliant and aligned with the firm's policies. Social media posts by advisors rose 40%.

Key Takeaways

1. Develop a Clear and Comprehensive Social Media Policy: A well-defined social media policy is the foundation of any successful compliance program. Clearly outline permissible and prohibited content, disclosure requirements, and the process for content approval.
2. Invest in Technology for Monitoring and Compliance: Automating social media monitoring and content approval is essential for effectively managing compliance risks. Consider implementing a platform like Hearsay Systems.
3. Prioritize Employee Training: Provide ongoing training to ensure that employees understand the firm's social media policy and how to create compliant content. Knowledge is power.
4. Regularly Review and Update Your Program: The regulatory landscape is constantly evolving, so it's important to regularly review and update your social media compliance program to ensure it remains effective. At least annually.
5. Document Everything: Maintain comprehensive records of all social media activity, compliance reviews, and employee training to demonstrate your commitment to compliance to regulators. This creates a valuable audit trail.

About Golden Door Asset

Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors improve client retention and accelerate growth. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.