Volatility Mitigation: Legacy Bridge Cuts Attrition by 12%
Executive Summary
Legacy Bridge Advisors faced significant client attrition during a period of market volatility, driven by client fear and uncertainty. To combat this, they implemented a proactive communication strategy encompassing regular market updates, webinars, and personalized consultations. This approach successfully reduced client attrition by 12%, preserving approximately $40.8 million in Assets Under Management (AUM) and reinforcing client trust in Legacy Bridge's long-term investment strategies.
The Challenge
Market downturns are an inevitable part of the investment landscape, but they often trigger a wave of client anxiety and, ultimately, attrition for Registered Investment Advisors (RIAs). Legacy Bridge Advisors experienced this firsthand during the first quarter of 2023, a period marked by rising inflation, interest rate hikes, and geopolitical uncertainty. The S&P 500 experienced a sharp correction of nearly 8% during this time, prompting widespread investor concern.
Prior to implementing a dedicated volatility mitigation strategy, Legacy Bridge historically saw an average client attrition rate of 4% per quarter. However, during the first quarter of 2023, the firm was on track to exceed this average substantially. Initial projections indicated a potential attrition rate of 7%, translating to a loss of approximately $23.8 million in AUM, based on their total AUM of $340 million at the time. This projected loss represented not only a reduction in revenue but also potential long-term damage to client relationships and brand reputation.
Adding to the challenge, many of Legacy Bridge's clients were nearing retirement or already retired, making them particularly sensitive to market fluctuations and the potential impact on their retirement savings. These clients were increasingly contacting advisors with questions about the safety of their portfolios and expressing concerns about their ability to maintain their desired lifestyle. The increased workload and the emotional toll of addressing these anxieties were also impacting advisor productivity and morale. Without a structured approach to address these concerns, Legacy Bridge risked losing valuable clients and suffering significant financial consequences. The firm understood that inaction would lead to a further erosion of client confidence and a potentially irreversible decline in AUM. The urgency to find a solution was paramount.
The Approach
Patricia Brennan, a Senior Financial Advisor at Legacy Bridge, spearheaded the development and implementation of a proactive communication strategy designed to address client anxieties and reinforce the firm's long-term investment philosophy. Brennan recognized that simply providing generic market commentary was insufficient. Clients needed personalized attention and reassurance that their individual financial plans were still on track, despite the market turbulence.
The strategy comprised three key components:
- Regular Market Updates: Legacy Bridge implemented a weekly email newsletter, "Market Insights," providing concise and easily digestible summaries of market performance, economic trends, and their potential impact on client portfolios. The newsletter avoided overly technical jargon and focused on clear, actionable information, such as rebalancing strategies and diversification benefits. The newsletter explicitly linked market movements back to client's long-term investment goals and the firm's strategic recommendations, creating transparency and promoting confidence in the overall strategy.
- Educational Webinars: Legacy Bridge hosted monthly webinars on topics relevant to client concerns, such as "Navigating Inflation in Retirement," "Understanding Market Volatility," and "Protecting Your Portfolio During Downturns." These webinars featured presentations from senior advisors, guest speakers (e.g., economists, tax specialists), and Q&A sessions, allowing clients to directly address their questions and concerns. The webinars were recorded and made available on the Legacy Bridge website for clients who couldn't attend live.
- Personalized Consultations: Brennan and her team proactively reached out to high-net-worth clients and those who had expressed particular concerns about market volatility to schedule one-on-one consultations. These consultations provided an opportunity to review individual financial plans, assess risk tolerance, and make any necessary adjustments to investment strategies. The advisors used this time to educate clients on the long-term benefits of staying invested during market downturns and to address any specific anxieties they might have. The consultation strategy focused on personalized financial planning for each client.
Brennan's approach also emphasized transparency and empathy. Advisors were trained to actively listen to client concerns, acknowledge their anxieties, and provide clear, honest explanations of market conditions and investment strategies. This fostered a sense of trust and collaboration, which was crucial for maintaining client confidence during a difficult period.
Furthermore, Legacy Bridge adopted a proactive approach to portfolio reviews, implementing a systematic process for identifying and addressing any potential issues before they became major concerns for clients. This involved regularly analyzing portfolio performance, assessing risk levels, and making adjustments as needed to ensure that portfolios remained aligned with client goals and risk tolerances. The firm also implemented a stress-testing framework to evaluate the potential impact of various market scenarios on client portfolios, allowing them to proactively identify and mitigate potential risks.
Technical Implementation
The successful execution of Legacy Bridge's volatility mitigation strategy relied on a combination of technology platforms and streamlined processes.
- Mailchimp: Legacy Bridge utilized Mailchimp for automated email distribution of the "Market Insights" newsletter. They created segmented email lists based on client demographics, investment goals, and risk tolerance to ensure that clients received relevant information. Mailchimp's reporting features also allowed Legacy Bridge to track open rates, click-through rates, and other engagement metrics, providing valuable insights into the effectiveness of their communication efforts. The newsletters included links to helpful resources and encouraged clients to schedule one-on-one consultations.
- GoToWebinar: GoToWebinar was used to host the monthly educational webinars. Legacy Bridge leveraged GoToWebinar's features for registration, audience management, and interactive Q&A sessions. The platform's recording capabilities allowed them to archive webinars and make them available on their website for on-demand viewing. Polls and surveys were used during the webinar to gauge the audience's understanding of the material and gather feedback for future sessions.
- Salesforce: Legacy Bridge used Salesforce, their existing CRM system, to track all client interactions related to the volatility mitigation strategy. This included logging phone calls, emails, meeting notes, and webinar attendance. Salesforce's reporting capabilities allowed them to monitor client engagement, identify clients who were at risk of attrition, and track the overall effectiveness of their communication efforts. Salesforce also helped the advisors maintain a consistent and personalized approach to client communication.
- Financial Planning Software (eMoney Advisor): Legacy Bridge used eMoney Advisor to conduct portfolio stress testing and to model the potential impact of market volatility on client's financial plans. This enabled them to provide clients with personalized illustrations of how their portfolios were positioned to withstand market downturns and to demonstrate the long-term benefits of staying invested. The software's Monte Carlo simulation capabilities provided a probabilistic assessment of the likelihood of achieving client's retirement goals under various market scenarios.
To calculate the AUM retention and attrition rates, Legacy Bridge used the following formulas:
- Attrition Rate = (AUM Lost Due to Client Departures / Beginning AUM) * 100
- Retention Rate = 100 - Attrition Rate
The firm also utilized data analytics tools within Salesforce to identify key drivers of client attrition, such as client demographics, portfolio characteristics, and communication patterns. This information was used to refine the communication strategy and to better target clients who were at risk of leaving.
Results & ROI
The proactive communication strategy implemented by Legacy Bridge yielded significant positive results, particularly in mitigating client attrition and preserving AUM.
- Reduced Client Attrition: The firm experienced a 12% reduction in client attrition during the first quarter of 2023, compared to initial projections. The actual attrition rate was 2.5%, significantly lower than the projected 7%. This represents a substantial improvement in client retention and a testament to the effectiveness of the communication strategy.
- Preserved AUM: The reduced attrition rate translated to the preservation of approximately $40.8 million in AUM. This figure was calculated based on the difference between the projected AUM loss ($23.8 million) and the actual AUM loss, which was considerably lower. This preserved AUM directly contributed to the firm's revenue and profitability.
- Increased Client Engagement: The "Market Insights" newsletter achieved an average open rate of 45% and a click-through rate of 15%, indicating strong client engagement with the firm's communication efforts. The webinars attracted an average of 150 attendees per session, demonstrating a high level of interest in the topics covered.
- Improved Client Satisfaction: Client satisfaction surveys revealed a significant increase in client confidence in Legacy Bridge's investment advice. The surveys showed a 20% increase in the number of clients who strongly agreed with the statement, "I am confident that Legacy Bridge is managing my investments in my best interests."
- Enhanced Advisor Productivity: While not directly quantifiable, advisors reported that the proactive communication strategy reduced the number of inbound client inquiries and allowed them to focus on more strategic tasks. The streamlined communication processes and readily available resources empowered advisors to address client concerns more efficiently.
The ROI of the volatility mitigation strategy was significant. The preservation of $40.8 million in AUM generated an estimated $306,000 in annual revenue (assuming a typical advisory fee of 0.75%). This revenue far outweighed the costs associated with implementing the communication strategy, which included the subscription fees for Mailchimp and GoToWebinar, as well as the time invested by advisors in creating and delivering the content.
Key Takeaways
Here are key takeaways for other RIAs facing similar challenges:
- Proactive Communication is Crucial: Don't wait for clients to reach out with concerns. Implement a proactive communication strategy that provides regular market updates, educational resources, and personalized consultations.
- Personalization Matters: Tailor your communication to individual client needs and risk tolerances. Segment your client base and deliver content that is relevant to their specific circumstances.
- Emphasize Long-Term Perspective: Reinforce your firm's long-term investment philosophy and help clients understand the importance of staying invested during market downturns.
- Leverage Technology: Utilize technology platforms like email marketing tools, webinar platforms, and CRM systems to streamline communication and track client engagement.
- Empower Your Advisors: Provide your advisors with the training, resources, and support they need to effectively communicate with clients and address their concerns.
About Golden Door Asset
Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors identify at-risk clients and proactively offer personalized solutions. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.